Games
Would you rather
Ask silly either-or questions, like trunk or tail, and take turns choosing and explaining why.
- Age
- 4 to 6 years
- Play time
- 15 min
- Set-up
- No prep
- Where
- Indoors or outdoors
- Who
- Any number of kids
- Clean-up
- Low mess
Over-fours have strong opinions, and this game gives them somewhere to put them. A silly choice, such as swimming in custard or in porridge, gets a quick answer and then a surprisingly long explanation. It fills car journeys, dinner tables and the walk to school with no equipment at all. Their own questions start out gross or nonsensical, and some of the best conversations you have all week will come from them.
How to play
-
Think up a few silly choices before you start, such as 'would you rather have a trunk like an elephant or a tail like a monkey?'
-
Ask the question and let your child pick. Then ask why, which is where the fun is.
-
Answer one yourself, with a reason, so they hear how it goes.
-
Take turns asking. Their questions may revolve around bottoms and ice cream for a while.
-
To stretch it, make the choice properly tricky, with two equally good or equally revolting options, or add a follow-up such as 'and what would you do first?'
What you need
- Nothing at all
What they are practising
- language. Explaining a choice with a reason means putting together longer sentences.
- creativity. Imagining life with a trunk, or a house made of cake, lets them play out ideas in words.
- turn taking. Asking and answering in turn keeps everyone listening, not just talking.
Make it easier
For a four-year-old, keep the choices concrete and close to home, like pancakes or porridge for breakfast every day forever.
Make it harder
A six-year-old can invent a choice where both options are equally tempting, and try to talk you into changing your answer.
Parents ask
- What if they cannot explain why?
- Offer a starter, such as 'is it because...', or give your own reason first. Some days the answer is just 'because it is funny', and that is allowed.
- Every question my child asks is about toilets. Should I steer away?
- It is very normal at this age and usually fades once the giggles wear off. Laugh at a couple, then suggest a theme such as animals or food for the next round.
- Can a younger sibling join in?
- Give the younger one simple two-way picks, like apple or banana, and let the older child help think them up. Everyone still gets a turn to answer.



